For decades, conversations about India’s population were largely framed around numbers: how many people the country had, how quickly its population was growing, and how population growth could be controlled. But population is not simply a matter of statistics. It is also about people’s choices, their access to healthcare and education, their economic circumstances, and the extent to which they have agency over their own lives.
Few people have witnessed the evolution of India’s development discourse as closely as Poonam Muttreja. Over four decades, her work has intersected with women’s rights, reproductive health, gender equality, livelihoods, philanthropy, institution-building and public advocacy.
In a conversation on Development Wala’s podcast, Decoding India’s Social Sector, Muttreja reflected on her journey, the changes she has seen in India, and why development efforts must remain grounded in people’s lived realities. Her reflections raise an important question for the development sector: as India changes, are our policies and programmes changing with the people they are meant to serve?
A Journey Shaped by Communities and Lived Realities, Poonam Muttreja
Muttreja describes her journey into the development sector as something that felt deeply personal from the beginning. As a young activist, she travelled across parts of India, spending time with communities and observing the realities faced by people living on the margins, particularly women and girls.
Growing up in a middle-class Punjabi family in Delhi, she was also conscious of gender discrimination within her own surroundings. Being the third daughter, she saw the comments and expectations her mother faced, experiences that influenced her understanding of how gender shapes people’s lives from an early age.
During her university years, she spent time in Delhi’s slums, working with leather workers from Dalit communities. She recalls trying to organise cooperatives and helping artisans access markets directly, even before she fully understood the formal concept of a cooperative.
These experiences shaped her understanding of poverty. It was not merely a question of income, she reflected, but also a lack of power, voice, choice and agency.
This perspective continued to influence her work across different organisations and areas, from peacebuilding and rehabilitation after the 1984 riots to environmental leadership and women’s reproductive health.
Later, she spent 16 years at the MacArthur Foundation, where she established its India office and worked with civil society leaders on women’s reproductive health, sexual rights and gender issues.
Her journey eventually led her to the Population Foundation of India, where she became Executive Director. Across these different roles, she sees a common thread: development must be about enabling people to make decisions and participate in shaping their own lives.
Why Development Must Shift Power Closer to People
One of Muttreja’s strongest observations is that development organisations should be careful about creating parallel systems when existing public institutions could be strengthened.
Rather than establishing alternatives to government schools, hospitals or public services, she believes organisations should consider how communities can participate in improving the systems already in place.
This approach requires working with several stakeholders simultaneously. Communities, government, civil society, media, researchers and political leadership all have roles to play. Sustainable change rarely comes from isolated interventions or small pilots operating independently.
India has seen many projects demonstrate promising results at a local level. But the challenge is to move beyond scattered pilots and build efforts that contribute to wider, lasting change.
This is a relevant lesson for NGOs and development practitioners. A successful intervention cannot be measured only by what happens within the boundaries of a project. Its ability to influence systems, build ownership and sustain progress also matters.
India Has Changed — But the Gender Conversation Is Not Over
Muttreja has witnessed considerable changes in India over the past four decades. Women’s education has expanded, literacy has improved, life expectancy has increased, and maternal and child mortality have declined. Women are also having fewer children than in previous generations.
She sees an important shift in how population is discussed in India: a movement away from an overriding focus on population control towards greater recognition of reproductive choice, rights and agency.
Yet she cautions against assuming that progress means the conversation is over.
The narratives around population may change, but the pressure on women can remain. Earlier, women were often criticised for having too many children. Today, in some settings, the discourse has shifted towards concerns about women having too few children.
Muttreja argues that both approaches risk treating women’s bodies as instruments of demographic policy.
The concern is not simply about the language used in policy debates. It is about who gets to make decisions. Women’s reproductive choices should not be shaped by fear, pressure or political narratives about the size of the population.
Reproductive health and population policy must begin with women’s dignity, agency and freedom to make informed decisions.
This is a particularly important perspective for organisations working on gender and health. A programme may aim to improve health outcomes, but its approach matters just as much as its stated objective. Information, services and support should expand people’s choices, not limit them.
India’s Demographic Transition Is Not One Story
India is going through a significant demographic transition, but the changes are not happening uniformly across the country.
States differ in fertility levels, age structures, migration patterns, economic opportunities and social conditions. Treating India as a single demographic story can lead to policies that overlook these differences.
Muttreja’s argument is that the central question needs to change. Instead of focusing primarily on reducing population numbers, India needs to prepare for the population it is becoming.
That means thinking about:
- Education and employment opportunities for young people.
- Healthcare and social protection for an ageing population.
- Reproductive health services that respect choice.
- Urban planning that responds to migration.
- Better integration and opportunities for people moving between states.
- Policies that reflect the different demographic and economic realities of individual states.
For development organisations, this has implications for programme design. The needs of a young population in one region may differ considerably from those of a state experiencing a faster ageing transition. Similarly, migration-related challenges require responses that consider both the communities people leave and the places where they settle.
Development programmes need to recognise these differences rather than assume that one intervention or policy framework will work everywhere.
Young People Are Making Different Choices. Are Institutions Listening?
The conversation also touches on the changing aspirations of young people.
Muttreja notes that today’s youth are growing up in a world marked by uncertainty. Their expectations, priorities and ideas about the future may differ from those of their parents. This includes decisions around education, employment, relationships, marriage and family.
Institutions, families and policymakers need to make a greater effort to understand these aspirations rather than assume that younger generations will follow established paths.
This is particularly relevant in the development sector, where programmes are often designed around assumptions about what young people need or want.
Listening to young people should not be a token exercise or an activity limited to consultations. Their experiences and perspectives need to inform the design of policies and programmes that directly affect them.
Understanding the population transition also means understanding the people experiencing it.
Storytelling, Media and the Persistence of Gender Stereotypes
Muttreja also begins discussing the role of storytelling and media in shaping social attitudes. Drawing on her experience with gender equality, she reflects on the difficulty of sustaining progress: gains can be made, only to face setbacks, and organisations may find themselves spending considerable effort protecting achievements already secured.
She points to the representation of women in television serials as an example of how popular media can reinforce regressive gender roles. The stereotypical portrayal of women within domestic conflicts can influence how audiences see women’s roles, aspirations and relationships.
This raises a wider question for development practitioners: how do we move beyond awareness campaigns and research reports to influence the attitudes that shape everyday life?
Evidence and policy are essential, but social norms are also reinforced through culture, family, entertainment and public conversation. Communicating ideas in ways that people connect with is an important part of social change.
The transcript provided for this episode ends during this discussion of storytelling and media, so the article does not attempt to draw conclusions about the remainder of that conversation.
What Four Decades in the Development Sector Can Teach Us
Muttreja’s experiences offer some useful reflections for people working in NGOs, public policy, gender, health and social development.
Development work requires listening before designing solutions. Spending time with communities can challenge assumptions that may otherwise shape programmes. Understanding the experiences of people is not an optional step; it is part of designing relevant interventions.
Change requires collaboration. Governments, communities, civil society, media and other stakeholders have different roles. Meaningful progress is more likely when they work towards shared objectives rather than operate in isolation.
People should have agency in the decisions affecting their lives. Development programmes should expand people’s choices and capabilities, not replace one set of restrictions with another.
Progress is not always linear. Gains in gender equality, health or education can face resistance and setbacks. Organisations need long-term commitment, not only short project cycles.
India needs context-sensitive approaches. The country’s demographic, social and economic realities vary widely. Policies and programmes must reflect these differences.
These are not lessons limited to population or reproductive health. They apply to development work across education, livelihoods, governance, public health and social inclusion.
Development Begins with Understanding People
India’s development conversation has evolved significantly over the past four decades. The questions being asked today are different from those that dominated earlier decades. But the need to ground development in people’s realities remains unchanged.
Population debates are a reminder of how easily people can become reduced to statistics, targets or policy concerns. Behind every demographic trend are individuals making decisions about their lives, often within circumstances that are not entirely of their choosing.
The development sector must continue to move towards approaches that recognise these realities. Policies need evidence. Programmes need context. Institutions need to listen. And progress must be measured not only by outcomes, but also by whether people have greater freedom, dignity and agency.
As Muttreja’s journey illustrates, meaningful social change is rarely the result of one intervention or one organisation. It is built over time through relationships, collective effort and a willingness to keep learning from the people at the centre of development.
About the Podcast
This conversation with Poonam Muttreja is part of Decoding India’s Social Sector, Development Wala’s podcast series featuring practitioners and leaders working across India’s development ecosystem.
Watch the full episode on YouTube :
About Development Wala
Development Wala is a platform working to strengthen India’s social sector by connecting people, organisations, opportunities and knowledge. Through its work across social sector recruitment, professional development, mentorship and knowledge sharing, Development Wala aims to contribute to a stronger development ecosystem.
View all Podcast episode: https://developmentwala.org/podcasts
Read other Blogs related to Social Sector : https://developmentwala.com/category/podcast/decoding-indias-social-sector/
Discover more from Development Wala
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.